Standard & Poor's revised outlooks on Kazakhstan-based Kazkommertsbank (JSC), JSC Nurbank, and AsiaCredit Bank to Stable; ratings affirmed
24.01.11 19:48
/IRBIS, January 24, 2011/ - Standard & Poor's Ratings Services said today it
revised its outlooks on Kazakhstan-based Kazkommertsbank (JSC) (KKB), JSC
Nurbank, and JSC AsiaCredit Bank to stable from negative, said in a statement
released today by the rating agency.
At the same time, the long- and short-term counterparty credit ratings on the
banks were affirmed. Standard & Poor's also assigned 'kzBB+' Kazakhstan
national scale rating to Nurbank.
The rating affirmations affect: the 'B/C' long- and short-term counterparty credit
ratings on KKB and Nurbank; and the 'B/B' long- and short-term counterparty
credit ratings on AsiaCredit Bank.
The outlook revisions reflect our view of the robust economic recovery in the
Republic of Kazakhstan. Standard & Poor's expects GDP growth to average 7%
between 2011 and 2013, underpinned by structural net inflows from foreign direct
investment and the prospect of a doubling of oil output by 2020.
The rating actions also reflect our opinion that the banking operating environment
in Kazakhstan has stabilized following the restructuring in 2010 of three of the
four defaulted banks. The pressure on Kazakh banks' asset quality, liquidity, and
profitability has, in view of Standard & Poor's, eased, following a period of
heightened risks over the past three years.
In the short to medium term, we expect ongoing improvements in asset quality
because Standard & Poor's believes that the deterioration bottomed out in 2010.
Analysts Standard & Poor's also expect to see the three banks maintain
adequate liquidity to meet wholesale debt repayments and customer deposit
withdrawals, especially from government-related entities, and adequate
capitalization to mitigate the high-risk economic and banking environment in
Kazakhstan. In January 2011, Standard & Poor's assigned a preliminary Banking
Industry Country Risk Assessment. A BICRA signals our view of the relative
riskiness of a country's banking industry on a scale of 1 to 10, ranging from the
lowest-risk banking industries (group 1) to the highest-risk banking industries
(group 10).
The ratings on the three banks are based on our assessment of their stand-alone
credit profiles and Standard & Poor's does not currently apply any uplift for
extraordinary parental or government support to these banks.
The rating actions on KKB reflect our belief that KKB will continue to benefit
from state support, given its high systemic importance according to our
classification. They also reflect our view of KKB's cautious and fairly efficient
business and operational adjustments and its efforts to reduce leverage, which
have helped it adapt to the challenging operating environment. The ratings on KKB
reflect KKB's weak asset quality, high dependence on foreign debt, limited
capitalization, and high single-name concentrations in corporate loans and
deposits. On the other hand, KKB has a good market position, particularly among
large Kazakh corporate clients, and adequate core revenue generation,
supported by aggressive cost management.
"In May 2009, the Kazakh government acquired a 21% stake in KKB through a
capital injection of KZT36 billion, but we understand it intends to exit KKB when
market conditions improve. Direct state funding accounts for slightly less than
10% of KKB's liabilities, but we estimate that about 40% of KKB's deposits relate
to state companies", - said in the statement.
Standard & Poor's expects the proportion of loans under stress, including
restructured loans, to reduce only moderately in 2011 from almost 48% on Sept.
30, 2010. This will continue to hurt KKB's capitalization and financial
performance. Wholesale debt repayments of about $700 million due in 2011 and
significant deposit concentrations will continue to challenge the bank's liquidity
management, according to Standard & Poor's.
The rating actions on Nurbank reflect Standard & Poor's view that the bank has
addressed its credit reserving needs through increased credit provisions at
midyear 2010, in conjunction with a capital injection at year-end 2010. The
ratings reflect our view of Nurbank's weak asset quality, high concentrations in
lending and funding, and sizable exposure to the troubled construction and real
estate sectors. These negative factors are partly offset by the bank's increased
capitalization and credit reserves, strengthened management team since the
beginning of 2010, and adequate liquidity management.
The level of reported nonperforming loans (NPLs; 90 days overdue) decreased in
2010 (8.9% at midyear 2010). However, we believe the proportion of loans under
stress, including restructured loans, is closer to 40%. Loan loss provisions of
23.4% of total loans at midyear 2010 are adequate, in our view, following a
significant increase. Standard & Poor's expects earnings to slowly recover from
2011 onward, after a material loss in the first half at 2010, as revenues pick up
and credit costs normalize.
A capital increase of KZT95.5 billion (about $650 million) in December 2010 by
the new shareholder to cover provision-related losses should have markedly
strengthened Nurbank's adjusted total equity-to-adjusted assets ratio to more
than 30% at year-end 2010. However, the ratio could have been undermined by
potential additional provisioning needs and high concentrations. Nurbank's
balance-sheet liquidity and funding profile are comfortable, according to Standard
& Poor's. Due to recent substantial foreign debt repayments and deposit growth,
the share of foreign debt in the bank's total liabilities declined to about 9.4%
at midyear 2010, which is below the sector average. However, large deposit and
loan concentrations remain, increasing roll-over risk.
The rating actions on AsiaCredit Bank reflect its decision to increase capital by
$100 million in 2010-2011 and our view of a positive trend in asset quality. The
ratings on AsiaCredit Bank reflect the bank's small domestic franchise, weak
asset quality and profitability, and aggressive growth plans. The ratings benefit
from our view of AsiaCredit Bank's strong capitalization, enhanced by a proposed
large capital increase and good short-term liquidity.
The bank's controlling shareholders - Kazakh businessmen Nurbol Sultan and
Chingiz Dosmuhambetov - plan to contribute $100 million (about KZT15 billion)
in capital in 2010-2011 to increase capitalization to the minimum regulatory
requirement and support the bank's medium-term growth strategy. The bank
received KZT7.4 billion from Mr. Sultan in September 2010, which is currently
registered as a deposit. This should result in a markedly stronger risk-adjusted
capital (RAC) ratio than the 18.9% after adjustments Standard & Poor's had
calculated as of year-end 2009, which was the highest among rated banks in
Kazakhstan.
In Standard & Poor's view, AsiaCredit Bank's asset quality is improving.
Reported NPLs (90 days overdue, including restructured and written-off loans)
fell to 10.8% on Sept. 30, 2010, from 13% at year-end 2009. Standard & Poor's
believes this is largely due to the bank's more-conservative growth rates than
peers' during the mid-2000s. Exposure to the construction and real estate
sectors (41% of total loans, including residential mortgages on Sept. 30, 2010)
heightens credit risk.
Standard & Poor's regards AsiaCredit Bank's funding and liquidity position as
adequate, reflected in an acceptable loan-to-deposit ratio of 117% as of Sept. 30,
2010, and no outstanding foreign debt repayments.
[2011-01-24]